Ultra Low Distortion HiFi VAS Amplifier stage

To build a low distortion (up to 20KHz) and high output power amplifier requires a ultra low distortion, low impedance output stage with an open loop gain exceeding 1MHz.

To realise such a design, and keep the noise figure as low as possible a large number of design considerations have been considered until a viable design (tested using SPICE simulations) is proposed. This work has taken years of thought and months of simulation and redesign.

The output stage will use MOSFET devices as opposed to bipolar, this has been chosen for the following reasons:-

  1. The inherent Rds limits the short circuit current sufficiently to permit the use of an external short circuit protection circuit to be used that does not contribute to amplifier distortion.
  2. The negative temperature coefficient of MOSFET simplifies the design of a thermally stable output stage.
  3. The higher frequency response permits a tighter feedback loop further reducing distortion.

Bipolar devices are capable of delivering equivalent performance, but with additional complexity, this often is at the expense of non linear audio distortion. Years of listening to bipolar vs MOSFET designs has proved MOSFET’s sound better, although MOSFET devices are more expensive, often require higher idle bias current and are harder to source.

The MOSFET output topology has been carefully considered and over 20 alternate topologies tried, some offer considerable cross over distortion reduction but at the price of difficult driving impedance or poor thermal stability. After months of experimentation, electrical and thermal modeling it has been decided to return to a traditional source follower approach.

Low Noise FET Input

The use of a FET input stage greatly reduces DC offset as it is a voltage amplifier as opposed to current hence input bias currents do not affect DC offsets. The matching of the input FET devices is aided by matched pairs, for this reason the LSK389 has been a popular choice. Sadly the high capacitance of the input, around 20pF greatly limited phase and frequency responses. The newer LSK489 is an ideal choice with only 4pF capacitance and 4.7uV/\sqrt Hz noise and superb Vgs matching reducing offset voltage errors, please refer to Bob Cordell’s LSK489 application note for more information.

The use of a temperature compensated constant current sink and cascaded FET drains yields the following differential topology:-

Differential Input Stage
Differential Input Stage

The voltage source is a low noise temperature compensated zenor device at 6.2V. This provides a 2mA sink current through R7. The power rails are +-60V, so the voltage on the source of the LSK489 devices is approximately 60 - (6.2V + 0.6V + 0.002mA * 20000 \Omega), -13.2V. Transistors Q3 and Q9 act as cascade to the LSK489 differential pair and reduce the voltage across the LSK489 device to:-

38000 \Omega * 60V / (120000 \Omega + 38000 \Omega) -0.6V = 13.8V

This places a maximum voltage of 27V across LSK489 – Well within it’s design parameters.

The filtering across the reference Zenor diode here is non optimal, the output impedance of the noise across D1 is low and should has a series resistor to reduce noise.

R5 and C7 place a pole at around 3MHz, limiting the differential bandwidth. The final design has a number of zero’s and poles to stabilize the amplifier and produce a favorable bode plot.

The cascoded FET stage also acts to reduce the voltages across the top current mirrors and low impedance drivers Q2, Q4, Q7 and Q8 which can be a very low noise, high frequency bipolar device. BC560C‘s were chosen here as they have suitable high gain.

Care was taken to match transistors in equal gain pairs, although the emitter degeneration reduces the effect of this.

MOSFET High Fidelity Output Stage

There are countless publications and designs for high-fidelity audio power amplifiers. As an audio engineer I have recently been designing a new power amplifier to replace my 3rd generation amplifier initially built over 25 years ago.

amp
Class AB amplifier using Hitachi Lateral MOSFETS

Much discussion has been made on “Square Law” and “Cube Law” amplifiers to reduce harmonic distortion by altering the drives to the output devices.

As an initial study, I simulated the following circuit in LTSpice and extracted a polynomial regression of the input and output data points. This then gives a clear indication of the transfer function. The following circuit:-

bipolar_mos_op
Bipolar Transistor driving MOSFET output

Running a spice simulation followed by a 5th term polynomial regression yielded the following equation:-

1.0371786 + 5.0875544x + 0.22985048x^2 -0.05428182x^3 + 0.005091393x^4

The 1.03 offset is unimportant, the 5.09 is the gain of the stage. The unwanted components are the square, cube and quadratic terms. The higher order terms produce greater distortion at higher signal amplitudes.

It is worth comparing this with the equivalent circuit using a MOSFET driver:-

output_fet_fet
MOSFET Output stage driving EXICON Lateral MOSFET

This produced the following polynomial:-

0.67743263 + 5.1414499x 0.14129363 x^2 -0.0204953^3 +0.0011353254x^4

Clearly the x^2 term is smaller as expected, but in addition the x^3 and x^4 terms are smaller. If we further reduce the gain to 2, by adjusting the feedback resistors we get:-

0.4495991+ 1.8448146x + 0.028082105x^2 -0.0040223748x^3 +0.00022303229x^4

If we can alter the drive to have -ve x^2 and x^3 terms we should be able to reduce distortion considerably. The largest distortion contribution is the x^2 component.

This work progressed to analysing hundreds of MOSFET output stages, the best design based on work suggested by Bob Cordell in his book Bob Cordell “Designing Audio Power Amplifiers”

This design has very low THD, but required additional complexity to the driving VAS stage. The distortion improvements in the output stage were lost in the additional complexity in the VAS driving stage.

The final decision was to use a conventional source following design with 3 pole miller compensation and careful VAS design. Most distortion is generated at +-1V where there s a transconductance imbalance. The initial design will ignore this and allow the feedback to cancel most of this error. The snag with -Ve feedback is it’s performance at higher frequencies, if the frequency response of the VAS stage is insufficient the error at 20KHz will be greater. We will consider the use of local error injection into the driver stage to reduce this error, hence reducing high frequency distortion.